We Both Song Lyrics

When I was with you, I was real
When I was with you, I could be myself
When I was with you, I didn't feel
Lost, confused or frightened
Or scared to be who I am
When I was with you, I was real

We both think you look great in a knit sweater
We both enjoy an empty cafe
We both are actual human beings to waiters
We both are not totally straight

None of that changes
None of that has changed

Okay?

Okay

We both like drinking hot tea in warm weather
We both like playing guitar
We both like when you tell me the plots of bad movies
We both forget our card at the bar
Almost always

When I was with you, I was real
When I was with you, I could be myself
When I was with you, I was real

Like as real as my retainer
That I left at your house one time
When I am with you, I am real

Now, do you remember what I said the first time we did the questions?
About my perfect day?

Yes
You said that tomorrow could be the perfect day if we let it be
That's not the kind of answer you forget
Especially when the person answering it is wearing a low-cut blouse

Mm, you thinking about my blouse?

I'm remembering it
Do you remember my answer?

Ehh, the broad strokes
Uh, picnic in the park with your family
A mini-muffin basket for lunch
Everyone getting together under a big blanket and watching the entire third season of The Office